By Scott Graham All Articles
The First District Court of Appeal has thrown out a $113,830 pregnancy discrimination award — and a $1.1 million attorney fee — obtained two years ago against Lucasfilm Ltd.
The case, brought by former San Francisco Supervisor Angela Alioto and her son, Joseph Alioto Veronese, on behalf of Veronese’s wife, Julie, appears to be something of a grudge match, with the appellate court describing “numerous discovery disputes” and a motion to recuse one of the trial judges for gender bias.
In the end, Justice James Richman concluded that Marin County Superior Court Judge Lynn O’Malley Taylor committed instructional error, primarily because she didn’t tell the jury it could not find Lucasfilm liable if the company simply relied on its business judgment when deciding not to hire Julie Veronese, as long as it was not for a discriminatory reason. … Continue Reading